Skip to main content
112/112H: College Writing

Second Place: Fear in Our Neighborhoods: ICE’s Shadow Over Western Massachusetts

Author
  • Asia Lam

How to Cite:

Lam, A., (2026) “Second Place: Fear in Our Neighborhoods: ICE’s Shadow Over Western Massachusetts,” Best Text Collection 6(1). doi: https://doi.org/10.7275/best_text.4072

Downloads:
Download HTML

156 Views

67 Downloads

Published on
2026-05-20

3de95137-3a86-4f00-8eb8-0b5e27012f9e

Asia Lam

Fear in Our Neighborhoods: ICE’s Shadow Over Western Massachusetts

Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant and Bar, a family-owned restaurant in Amherst, Massachusetts, temporarily shut its doors after rumors spread that ICE had conducted a raid and detained five employees the previous evening. The restaurant’s owner, Federico Mendiola, later confirmed to the Daily Hampshire Gazette that no raid had actually occurred, but the mere rumor of ICE activity was enough to spread fear throughout the community. UMass has a diverse student and worker population: This affects classmates, campus workers, and the broader community we are a part of. When ICE activity forces restaurants to close, workers to stay home, and families to live in fear, it creates an environment of instability that extends to the university itself. As Immigration and Customs Enforcement efforts continue to cast uncertainty over daily life, understanding their impact on local immigrant communities becomes essential to fostering a more supportive environment.

These attacks don’t come out of nowhere, they’re enabled by federal programs like 287(g) and Secure Communities, which allow local law enforcement to collaborate with ICE. The 287(g) program trains local officers to enforce immigration laws, while Secure Communities shares fingerprints of individuals arrested with both local law enforcement and ICE, triggering deportation proceedings if the person is undocumented. While both programs aim to identify and deport individuals with criminal records, critics argue they lead to racial profiling and undermine trust in local police. However, Massachusetts has pushed back with several cities, including Amherst, that have adopted sanctuary policies that limit cooperation with ICE. These policies ensure that local law enforcement does not cooperate with ICE, protecting immigrant communities by preventing the sharing of immigration status or detaining individuals at ICE’s request unless serious crimes are involved. As of Bylaw Section 3.9, the Town of Amherst officials have stated that Amherst’s sanctuary policy reaffirms its commitment to safeguarding the rights of immigrants and ensuring that all residents can engage with public services without fear. While these policies offer some protection, they do not entirely prevent federal agents from operating in the area.

Due to a recent executive order signed by President Trump, the acting Homeland Security Secretary, Benjamin Huffman, issued two directives as of January, the first of which allows ICE and CBP to conduct raids and deport unauthorized migrants in places like schools and churches. This expansion of enforcement zones heightens the fear within immigrant communities, further discouraging individuals from seeking essential services or engaging with their communities. Parents are now living with the constant anxiety that they might be detained, leaving their children vulnerable or without care, or even their very own children being taken and not being able to be there to help. Children are affected emotionally, facing the fear of losing their parents or being separated in case of a raid. Little kids, some barely old enough to read, are being treated like threats. What harm have they done? What can they do? Why strip away their innocence for something they can’t even comprehend? This creates a cycle of stress that affects the entire family unit.

The contradiction arises from the tension between local sanctuary policies and federal immigration enforcement. While Amherst’s sanctuary policy limits cooperation with ICE, the federal directive allows ICE to conduct raids in sensitive locations like schools and churches, leaving many immigrant families in a state of uncertainty. Similarly, neighboring Holyoke has taken a firm stance against excessive enforcement. In a public statement, Mayor Joshua A. Garcia reaffirmed that the Holyoke Police Department will not honor civil immigration detainers from ICE who seek to prolong an individual's detention unnecessarily. "We stand by our commitment to protect the rights and safety of everyone who lives or works in our community," Garcia stated. Local organizations like the Pioneer Valley Workers Center work to provide legal assistance, but the need far outweighs the resources available. This reflects a growing local resistance to federal immigration enforcement, even as the reach of ICE expands.

However, the impact of fear extends beyond direct enforcement. According to Garcia’s owner, Federico Mendiola, “Since we know that there are rumors of them (ICE) being in the area, several local (Amherst) businesses have decided to close down to avoid harassment.” This fear-driven response demonstrates how ICE, and the broader U.S. immigration enforcement system, thrive on the anxiety they create. False reports and exaggerated enforcement numbers contribute to a sense of unpredictability, making immigrant communities hesitant to go about their daily lives, even when actual raids have not occurred. The resulting instability affects businesses, families, and entire neighborhoods, reinforcing a cycle of fear and economic disruption.

Research has shown that ICE activity not only leads to fear but also has serious health consequences for immigrant communities. A study published in the Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved highlights how increased ICE raids, detentions, and deportations contribute to heightened levels of stress, anxiety, and limited access to healthcare among undocumented individuals. Many immigrants avoid seeking medical attention due to fear of being reported, leading to untreated illnesses and worsened health conditions. Healthcare providers have noted an increase in cases of depression and post-traumatic stress disorder among children and families affected by ICE enforcement. This past month, at least 10 people were detained by federal agents in a series of immigration raids across Berkshire County. Community organizer Fernando Leon, who works with Berkshire Interfaith Organizing, said, “We have three kids in Pittsfield High School (~1 hour away from Amherst) that didn't have fathers to come home to. So, fortunately, those kids have connections in the community, they have families that came and picked them up, but what happens when they don't? What's the school district going to do with those kids? What's the community going to do with those kids? Because if it's left to the Pittsfield school district, if it's left to government, they might surrender those kids to [the Department of Children and Families], and we don't want that.” The psychological toll is immense, not only for the children directly affected but for entire communities. This effect further worsens health disparities and deepens community instability.

The same study also found that many healthcare providers were unaware of their patients’ immigration status, which highlights a critical gap in patient-provider communication. This lack of awareness, whether due to patient fear, time constraints in emergency settings, or a lack of training among providers, further exacerbates health disparities. Additionally, frequent relocations caused by deportation threats make it difficult for providers to follow up on care, leading to deteriorating health conditions such as uncontrolled diabetes and hypertension. Beyond the individual level, this fear erodes trust in the healthcare system and weakens the social fabric of communities, fostering isolation and deepening inequalities. The study’s findings show the urgent need for healthcare providers to create safe spaces for immigrant patients, implement policies that reassure them of confidentiality, and advocate for broader protections that prevent fear from becoming a barrier to essential medical care.

The reach of federal immigration enforcement has now struck the heart of UMass Amherst itself. As of April 6, 2025, five UMass Amherst students had their visas abruptly revoked and student statuses terminated by the federal government. Following 5 days later, another eight students also had their visas revoked, reported by the Amherst Indy. Chancellor Javier Reyes announced that the university was not informed in advance and only learned of the changes through its own monitoring of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) database. In some cases, these revocations were reportedly triggered by minor infractions, such as off-campus traffic violations. Unlike previous procedures where students could remain in the U.S. if enrolled, this new practice of simultaneously revoking SEVIS status creates immediate vulnerability to detention and deportation. The chancellor described these actions as “troubling on several levels,” and emphasized the university’s commitment to support its international students through legal aid, financial resources, and advocacy. However, this incident reveals how sanctuary policies and university protections may offer limited shelter in the face of aggressive federal enforcement. What once seemed like distant political decisions now emerge directly within classrooms and student lives, adding yet another layer of fear to already marginalized communities.

Western Massachusetts is in a state of crisis. From downtown restaurants to rural high schools, and now to the very campus of UMass Amherst, immigrant communities are being systematically destabilized by a federal immigration system designed to intimidate and punish. Despite sanctuary policies, legal aid networks, and public declarations of solidarity, ICE continues to spread immense fear by tearing families apart and driving people away from schools, hospitals, and community life. The abrupt revocation of student visas without warning or due process marks a terrifying new chapter in this escalating war on immigrants. Students are angry, scared, and heartbroken. We are betrayed not only by the Trump administration’s cruel policies, but by the federal government’s utter disregard for human dignity. What we’re seeing is an abuse of government systems. Trump’s directives have made it easier for federal agents to operate in schools, churches, and now universities, further threatening the basic sense of safety that everyone deserves. It’s no longer just a political issue: it’s our classmates, our coworkers, and our neighbors.

Works Cited

Pioneer Valley Workers Center, https://pvworkerscenter.org/worker-committees-page/. “The 287(g) Program: An Overview.” American Immigration Council, January 2025, https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/287g-program-immigration.

Feyre, Ryan. “Springfield schools address ICE mass deportation concerns.” The Reminder, February 2025, https://thereminder.com/local-news/hampden-county/springfield/springfield-schools-addr ess-ice-mass-deportation-concerns/.

Hacker, Karen, et al. “Provider's Perspectives on the Impact of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Activity on Immigrant Health.” Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, vol. 23, Johns Hopkins University Press, 2012, pp. 651-665. Project Muse, https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/1/article/474046/summary.

Keene, Art. “Visas Revoked for 13 UMass Amherst Students. Trend Accelerates Across the Nation's Campuses.” Amherst Indy, 12 April 2025, https://www.amherstindy.org/2025/04/11/visas-revoked-for-13-umass-amherst-internatio nal-students-trend-accelerates-across-the-nations-campuses/.

Klein, Emilee. “No ICE raids in region this week, but rumors whipped fear throughout immigrant community.” Daily Hampshire Gazette, January 2025, https://www.gazettenet.com/Rumors-of-ICE-raids-brew-fear-among-the-Hispanic-Comm unity-59199375?fbclid=IwY2xjawJP5R5leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHcrs3cAkKBthh_tpPFI 3p473Ag4BL8qlYX3CAZCY6QN3rWcphxk1-N1HXA_aem_hJ2c-Inm-pSlVZdhPOEar w.

Landes, Josh. “Unprecedented crackdown sees ICE agents detain at least 10 Berkshire community members in sweep.” Northeast Public Radio, March 2025, https://www.wamc.org/news/2025-03-21/unprecedented-crackdown-sees-ice-agents-detai n-at-least-10-berkshire-community-members-in-sweep.

Reyes, Javier. “Immigration actions affecting students on UMass-sponsored visas.” University of Massachusetts Amherst, April 2025, https://www.umass.edu/news/article/immigration-actions-affecting-students-umass-spons ored-visas.

“Secure Communities: A Fact Sheet.” American Immigration Council, November 2011, https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/secure-communities-fact-sheet.

Shook, Ashley, and Victoria Buddie. “Holyoke works to protect rights of migrants in city.” WWLP, January 2025, https://www.wwlp.com/news/local-news/hampden-county/holyoke-works-to-protect-right s-of-migrants-in-city/.

“Statement Reaffirming Amherst as Sanctuary Community.” Town of Amherst, November 2024, https://www.amherstma.gov/CivicAlerts.aspx?AID=3692&ARC=7121#:~:text=The%20 Town%20of%20Amherst%20is,nation%20and%20to%20our%20community.